Clergyman's

Words, and Quotes

The third preliminary problem for every theory of reality is that of the experience of transcendence. We saw in the case of Berkeley that his erroneous principle *percipi est esse*, and his assertion that any being which we think, just for the reason that it is thought, cannot at the same time be regarded as subsisting independently of thinking, incorporate a failure to recognize the consciousness of transcendence peculiar to all intentional acts. This is an instance of the failure to recognize that not only all thinking in the narrower sense, in the sense of grasping an object on the basis of “meanings” and grasping a state of affairs through judgments, but *every* intention in general, whether perception, representation, remembering, the feeling of value, or the posing of ends and goals, points beyond the act and the contents of the act and intends something other than the act [*ein Aktfremdes*], even when what is thought is in turn itself a thought. Indeed, *intentio* signifies a goal-directed movement toward something which one does not have oneself or has only partially and incompletely. Berkeley (following Locke, who was the first to make the basic philosophical error which introduced “psychologism” into epistemology) arrived at the principle *esse est percipi* by making the idea [*Vorstellung*] (and even the sensation) into a thing, an immaterial substance, and by failing to distinguish between the act, the content of an act, and the object. Furthermore, Berkeley confused the being of objects with the fact of being-an-object, even though the latter has only a loose and variable connection with the former. On the other hand, the transcendence of the intentional object with respect to both the *intentio* and its present content is common to every instance of being-an-object. It is, for instance, proper to objects of pure mathematics which are certainly not real but ideal (for example, the number 3). These are produced from the *a priori* material of intuition in accordance with an operational law governing the steps of our thought or intuition. Transcendence is further proper to all fictitious objects and even to contradictory objects, for instance, a square circle. All these sorts of objects, e.g., the golden mountain or Little Red Riding Hood, satisfy the basic principle of the transcendence of objects over and above that aspect of them which is, at any moment, given in consciousness, just as much as do real objects existing independently of all consciousness and knowledge."?from_Idealism and Realism_
— Max Scheler

SAVE:
DESIGN:
CUSTOM BG:
FONT:
RATIO:
RES:
BG
PAT
TEXT
FRAME

The third preliminary problem for every theory of reality is that of the experience of transcendence. We saw in the case of Berkeley that his erroneous principle *percipi est esse*, and his assertion that any being which we think, just for the reason that it is thought, cannot at the same time be regarded as subsisting independently of thinking, incorporate a failure to recognize the consciousness of transcendence peculiar to all intentional acts. This is an instance of the failure to recognize that not only all thinking in the narrower sense, in the sense of grasping an object on the basis of “meanings” and grasping a state of affairs through judgments, but *every* intention in general, whether perception, representation, remembering, the feeling of value, or the posing of ends and goals, points beyond the act and the contents of the act and intends something other than the act [*ein Aktfremdes*], even when what is thought is in turn itself a thought. Indeed, *intentio* signifies a goal-directed movement toward something which one does not have oneself or has only partially and incompletely. Berkeley (following Locke, who was the first to make the basic philosophical error which introduced “psychologism” into epistemology) arrived at the principle *esse est percipi* by making the idea [*Vorstellung*] (and even the sensation) into a thing, an immaterial substance, and by failing to distinguish between the act, the content of an act, and the object. Furthermore, Berkeley confused the being of objects with the fact of being-an-object, even though the latter has only a loose and variable connection with the former. On the other hand, the transcendence of the intentional object with respect to both the *intentio* and its present content is common to every instance of being-an-object. It is, for instance, proper to objects of pure mathematics which are certainly not real but ideal (for example, the number 3). These are produced from the *a priori* material of intuition in accordance with an operational law governing the steps of our thought or intuition. Transcendence is further proper to all fictitious objects and even to contradictory objects, for instance, a square circle. All these sorts of objects, e.g., the golden mountain or Little Red Riding Hood, satisfy the basic principle of the transcendence of objects over and above that aspect of them which is, at any moment, given in consciousness, just as much as do real objects existing independently of all consciousness and knowledge."?from_Idealism and Realism_
— Max Scheler

Abhijit Naskar (83) Abraham Lincoln (97) Albert Camus (148) Albert Einstein (181) Aldous Huxley (92) Ambrose Bierce (98) Amit Kalantri (145) Amy Leigh Mercree (319) Anonymous (85) Anthony T. Hincks (248) Aristotle (126) Arthur Schopenhauer (82) Ayn Rand (101) Barack Obama (105) Benjamin Disraeli (95) Benjamin Franklin (127) Bertrand Russell (125) Blaise Pascal (88) C. JoyBell C. (213) C. S. Lewis (198) Cassandra Clare (226) Charles Bukowski (94) Christopher Hitchens (91) Chuck Palahniuk (124) Compton Gage (177) Confucius (82) Criss Jami (190) Debasish Mridha (1040) Douglas Adams (83) Elizabeth Gilbert (115) Emily Dickinson (86) Ernest Hemingway (99) Francis Bacon (88) Francois de La Rochefoucauld (109) Friedrich Nietzsche (237) George Bernard Shaw (149) George Eliot (91) George Orwell (92) H. L. Mencken (93) Haruki Murakami (123) Henry David Thoreau (187) Hillary Clinton (87) Honore de Balzac (82) J. K. Rowling (232) Jane Austen (116) Janvier Chouteu-Chando (144) Jerry Saltz (136) Jodi Picoult (112) Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (117) John F. Kennedy (86) John Green (133) Jr. (238) Lao Tzu (81) Leo Tolstoy (106) Lucius Annaeus Seneca (90) Mahatma Gandhi (160) Marcus Aurelius (91) Marcus Tullius Cicero (97) Marilyn Monroe (88) Mark Twain (220) Matshona Dhliwayo (141) Maya Angelou (82) Mensah Oteh (188) Mitch Albom (83) Mitt Romney (110) Mokokoma Mokhonoana (111) Neil Gaiman (135) Nicholas Sparks (148) Oscar Wilde (214) Paulo Coelho (190) Plato (131) Ralph Waldo Emerson (223) Ray Bradbury (82) Richelle Mead (115) Rick Riordan (176) Robert Frost (89) Roy T. Bennett (250) Samuel Butler (91) Samuel Johnson (97) Santosh Kalwar (109) Shannon L. Alder (94) Soren Kierkegaard (81) Stephen King (137) Stephen Richards (157) Steve Jobs (81) Steve Maraboli (212) Sunday Adelaja (227) Suzy Kassem (155) T. S. Eliot (81) Tamil (103) Terry Pratchett (123) Thomas Jefferson (111) Toba Beta (189) Unknown (638) Victor Hugo (141) Virginia Woolf (105) Voltaire (126) Walt Whitman (88) William Shakespeare (231) Winston Churchill (87)